Jumbo Peanut Butter Cups – Slice & Share
Price range: $15.98 through $47.94 Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Candy
-
-
- Baby Shower
- Best SellersOur Most Loved Candies These customer favorites have stood the test of time. Shop our best sellers and see why generations keep coming back to O’Shea’s for timeless treats.
- Boxed ChocolatesClassic Boxed Chocolates for Every Occasion Thoughtfully packaged and handcrafted, our boxed chocolates are perfect for gifting—or keeping for yourself. Choose from assorted milk, dark, or custom selections.
- Brand New ItemsDiscover What’s New at O’Shea’s Candies From delicious flavor pairings to seasonal treats, our newest sweets are here to surprise and delight. Explore the latest handmade candies fresh from our kitchen.
- Brittles & Caramel CornsOld-Fashioned Brittle & Fresh Caramel Corns Sweet, crunchy, and made from scratch, our brittle and caramel corns blend nostalgic flavors with handmade quality that everyone can enjoy!
- Candy BarsArtisan Candy Bars, O’Shea’s Style These aren’t your average candy bars. Each one is crafted in-house with rich chocolate and mouthwatering fillings, making them the perfect sweet treat for any occasion.
- Chocolate BarksHandmade Chocolate Barks with a Crunch Snap into rich, handcrafted chocolate blended with nuts, fruits, and more. Our chocolate bark is a flavorful, textured treat you’ll crave again and again.
- Chocolate Covered BerriesChocolate-Dipped Berries, Bursting with Flavor Juicy, vibrant berries meet smooth chocolate for an indulgent experience. Our chocolate-covered berries are the ultimate treat for fruit and chocolate lovers alike.
- Chocolate Molds
- ChristmasCelebrate the Magic of Christmas with O’Shea’s Candies Make the season sweeter with handcrafted holiday chocolates and nostalgic treats made right here in Western PA. From festive gift boxes and stocking stuffers to irresistible classics like hand-dipped peanut butter cups and coconut cream Penn Pigs, our Christmas collection has delicious delights for everyone on your list. Whether you’re gifting to loved ones or indulging in a seasonal favorite, O’Shea’s Candies brings tradition, craftsmanship, and holiday joy to every bite.
-
- Custom Logo Plaques & Business Cards
- EasterHop into Easter with Sweet Spring Treats From chocolate bunnies to colorful confections, our Easter collection is perfect for baskets, brunches, and joyful celebrations.
- Founder’s FavoritesO’Shea’s Signature Picks Discover the candies that started it all. These handpicked favorites are inspired by the legacy and taste of our founder, made with the same care and tradition.
- FudgeRich, Creamy Fudge Made the Old-Fashioned Way Handmade in small batches, our fudge is a smooth, melt-in-your-mouth classic available in a variety of irresistible flavors.
- Gourmet Chocolate TraysElegant Gourmet Chocolate Trays Ideal for entertaining or gifting, our chocolate trays are artfully arranged with an irresistible mix of O’Shea’s finest handmade confections.
- Gourmet PopcornSweet & Savory Gourmet Popcorn Air-popped and coated with a range of tasty flavorings, our gourmet popcorn brings a satisfying crunch in every bite. Perfect for movie nights, parties, or snacking on the go.
- Gourmet TrufflesDecadent Gourmet Chocolate Truffles Luxuriously smooth and rich in flavor, our gourmet truffles are handcrafted for true chocolate lovers. Treat yourself—or someone special.
- MintsRefreshingly Sweet Mints Cool, crisp, and oh-so-smooth, our handcrafted mints offer a refreshing finish to any meal—or a quick pick-me-up anytime.
- Non-ChocolateNon-Chocolate Candies That Shine Looking for a treat aside from chocolate? From fruity delights to hard candy classics, our non-chocolate treats are full of bold flavors and handmade goodness.
- NostalgicNostalgic Candy That Takes You Back Relive sweet memories with candies from days gone by. Our nostalgic collection features classic confections that are as delightful now as ever.
-
- NoveltyFun & Whimsical Candy Treats These creative sweets are perfect for kids and the young at heart. Explore our novelty candies for seasonal fun and playful gifting ideas.
- NutsChocolate-Covered & Roasted Nuts From buttery cashews to chocolate-drenched almonds, our premium nuts are perfect for snacking, gifting, or satisfying your crunchy cravings.
- O’Shea’s Associates Favorites
- Panned ChocolateChocolate-Covered Classics You’ll Love Our panned chocolates feature carefully selected ingredients, like almonds and fruit, coated in layers of fine chocolate. The result is a glossy, bite-sized treat that’s full of flavor and made to satisfy.
- Pretzels & ChipsSweet Meets Salty: Chocolate Pretzels & Chips A crowd favorite! Our chocolate-dipped pretzels and potato chips strike a tasty balance of salty and sweet with each irresistible crunch.
- Smash CupcakesSmash Cupcakes: A Chocolate Lover’s Dream Layered, loaded, and drizzled in chocolate, our Smash Cupcakes are a crowd-pleasing blend of cupcake and candy in one unforgettable dessert.
- Sugar FreeSugar-Free Candy That Doesn’t Compromise on Taste Enjoy guilt-free indulgence with our delicious sugar-free candies. Handmade with care, they’re perfect for anyone looking for a lower-sugar option.
- Valentine's DayValentine’s Day Candy to Say “I Love You” Make hearts melt with handcrafted Valentine’s Day treats. From chocolate hearts to love-themed assortments, every bite says “you’re sweet.”
- VeganVegan Candy, Crafted with Care Plant-based and full of flavor, our vegan candies let everyone enjoy the magic of O’Shea’s—without compromising on quality or taste.
- Wedding Flavors
-
-
- Sweet & SavorySweet & Savory – A Taste for Every Craving At O’Shea’s Candies, we believe treats should do more than just satisfy — they should surprise and delight. That’s why our Sweet & Savory collection brings together a carefully curated mix of cravings-worthy goodies: from crunchy cookies and buttery nut rolls to rich toffees, silky spreads, and even delightful syrups and honeys. Whether you’re after a cozy snack, a thoughtful gift, or something to elevate your coffee break — there’s a little something here for every mood, every moment, and every taste.
- CoffeeFresh Ground Coffee for the Perfect Pick-Me-Up At O’Shea’s Candies, our love for flavor goes beyond sweets. Our fresh ground coffee is carefully selected and expertly roasted to bring out rich, aromatic notes in every cup. Whether you’re starting your day or savoring a quiet moment, our coffee delivers the comfort and quality you deserve.
- CookiesCookies Treat yourself to small-batch cookies baked with old-fashioned care and big, unforgettable flavor. From classic chocolate chip and soft sugar cookies to bright lemon varieties and gourmet assortments, Otterbeins Cookies bring homemade comfort to every bite. Perfect for gift-giving or enjoying with your favorite warm drink.
- FruitFlavorful Dried Fruits for a Naturally Sweet Treat We believe great taste should be enjoyed in every form, which is why we offer a delightful selection of premium dried fruits. Each piece is chosen for its freshness, vibrant flavor, and satisfying texture, making it a wholesome snack you’ll want to reach for any time of day.
- Gourmet PopcornSweet & Savory Gourmet Popcorn Air-popped and coated with a range of tasty flavorings, our gourmet popcorn brings a satisfying crunch in every bite. Perfect for movie nights, parties, or snacking on the go.
- Honey & SyrupHoney & Syrup Experience the golden sweetness of our premium honey and syrup selection. Whether you’re drizzling over breakfast, baking holiday favorites, or gifting something naturally delicious, these rich, flavorful staples elevate every recipe and treat.
- Nut RollsNut Rolls Enjoy tradition at its finest with our fresh-baked walnut rolls. Soft, tender dough wraps around generous layers of sweet walnut filling for a classic treat that never goes out of style. Perfect for holiday gatherings, gifting, or savoring with your morning coffee.
- Scamps ToffeeScamps Toffee Indulge in handcrafted toffee made with rich butter, smooth chocolate, and the perfect crunch. Scamps Toffee is a gourmet delight that balances sweetness and texture in every bite. A thoughtful gift or an indulgent treat for yourself, it’s a beloved favorite for any occasion.
- SpreadsSpreads Add a touch of sweetness to your day with our collection of artisan spreads, including maple, cinnamon, sweet orange cardamom, and chocolate raspberry. Perfect on toast, pastries, or paired with your favorite baked goods, these unique flavors bring warmth, richness, and creativity to every snack or recipe.
- Fundraising
- Holidays
- Christmas
- EasterHandmade Easter Candy & Gifts Fill every Easter basket with joy. From chocolate eggs to spring-themed treats, our Easter selection adds cheer to any celebration.
- Mothers Day & Fathers Day
- Valentine’s DayValentine’s Day Gifts & Candy Celebrate love with handcrafted chocolates and festive Valentine’s Day gifts. Whether for a sweetheart, friend, or yourself, sweetness is guaranteed.
- Gifts
- Corporate Gifts & BasketsHandcrafted Corporate Gifting Made Easy Say “thank you” with thoughtful, delicious gifts. Our corporate selections are handcrafted to impress clients, colleagues, and partners alike.
- Gift CardsShop O’Shea’s Candies Top 12 Best Sellers We’ve curated a selection of our top 12 customer favorites, reflecting our dedication to handcrafted, high-quality. confections. This collection features a variety of treats, and each item is available in multiple sizes and chocolate types, catering to diverse preferences. This assortment offers. something delightful for every chocolate enthusiast!
- Ice Cream
- Life is Good®
- About
- Contact Us
- Wholesale
