A Scoop for Every Kind of Craving

Ice cream should never be one-note—and ours definitely isn’t. Our menu is packed with classic flavors, fun and colorful favorites, and rich, indulgent blends that keep customers coming back to try “just one more.”

Classic Ice Cream Favorites

Sometimes, simple is perfect. These timeless flavors are creamy, comforting, and never go out of style:

  • Old-Fashioned Vanilla & Vanilla Bean
  • Rich Chocolate & Award-Winning Chocolate
  • Strawberry, Peach, and Raspberry
  • Butter Pecan, Maple Walnut, and Praline Pecan
  • Coffee & Cappuccino-inspired blends

Perfect on their own—or as the base for your own custom creation.

Fun, Colorful & Crowd-Pleasing Flavors

Looking for something playful? These fan favorites are especially popular with kids (and kids at heart):

  • Superman®
  • Cotton Candy
  • Blue Moon
  • Birthday Cake
  • Playdough & Crazy Vanilla Rainbow

Bright colors, sweet flavors, and pure joy in every scoop.

Decadent Mix-Ins & Loaded Creations

If you believe ice cream should be packed with goodies, this section is for you. These flavors are full of swirls, chunks, cookies, cups, and crunch:

  • Moose Tracks® & Chocolate Moose Tracks®
  • Peanut Butter Cup, Peanut Butter Pie & Peanut Butter Twist
  • Cookies & Cream & Cookie Dough varieties
  • Brownie Batter, Brookie Dough & Chocolate Extreme
  • Salted Caramel, Truffle, and Cheesecake flavors

Every bite delivers something a little different—and a lot delicious.

Penn State Berkey Creamery Ice Cream

We’re proud to offer a rotating selection of Penn State Berkey Creamery Ice Cream, known nationwide for its ultra-rich texture and iconic flavors. These super-premium scoops are a must-try for true ice cream lovers.
Popular flavors include:

  • Death by Chocolate
  • Scholar Chip
  • Grilled Stickies
  • Peachy Paterno
  • Monkey Business
  • WPSU Coffee Break
  • Happy Happy Joy Joy

It’s ice cream with a legacy—and you can taste the difference.

More Than Just Ice Cream

In the mood for something a little lighter or different? We’ve got you covered.
Italian Ice & Sherbet
Cool, refreshing, and bursting with flavor—perfect on warm days or as a dairy-free option:

  • Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Mango & Lemon Italian Ice
  • Rainbow & Tie-Dye blends
  • Orange & Raspberry Sherbet
  • Reduced Fat & No Sugar Added Options

Enjoy ice cream your way with select Reduced Fat, No Sugar Added (RFNSA) flavors, including vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and butter pecan.

Try a Classic—or Create Your Own Combination

One of the best parts about visiting O’Shea’s Candies? Mixing and matching ice cream flavors to find your perfect pairing. Go traditional with vanilla and chocolate, or get adventurous with peanut butter, caramel, fruit, and cookie combinations.
Whether you’re stopping in for a cone, a cup, or a shared treat with family and friends, our ice cream menu is designed for discovery, nostalgia, and pure enjoyment.

Stop In & Scoop Something Special

Ice cream should be fun, flavorful, and made with care—and that’s exactly what you’ll find at O’Shea’s Candies. With an ever-changing selection and trusted brands like Hershey’s® Ice Cream and Penn State Berkey Creamery, there’s always a reason to come back for another scoop!